Amid a soaring suicide rate among soldiers, it's worth looking at how
the Army's aggressive video games distort our impressions of war.
By Jamie Holmes
December 28, 2009
For the first time since the establishment of all-volunteer forces in
1973, the US military has met all of its recruiting goals.
This success can be attributed in part to the new video games and
graphic novels aimed at America's youth. It may sound like the US
military has solved a major recruitment problem, but there may be a high cost.
In another first, suicides among US soldiers have hit a post-Vietnam
War high for the fifth year in a row.
Though the record suicide rate cannot be traced to a single causal
factor, specialists cite the psychological trauma of killing, an
American culture of denial, financial difficulties, failed
relationships, substance abuse, and post-traumatic stress disorder as
main contributors to the trend.
Despite the five-year span, Army Vice Chief of Staff Peter Chiarelli
admitted recently the US Army was still short the 300 substance abuse
counselors and 800 behavioral specialists needed to cope with the problem.
Though the US military professes concern for the psychological health
of its service members, this personnel gap is just one example of the
strong evidence to the contrary. The current recruiting tactics aimed
at America's youth are especially concerning. Not only do the very
tactics that have been boosting recruitment sanitize war and create
false expectations, they prey upon the vulnerable imaginations of children.
Throughout 2009 the military has aggressively expanded its marketing
campaign targeting teenagers. Efforts include the release of Version
3 of the taxpayer-sponsored video game America's Army, two graphic
novels that look and read like comic books, and a unique
14,500-sq.-ft. arcade – or "Army Experience Center" – in a
Philadelphia mall that is filled with simulators and shooter video games.
One reason for the armed forces' recruiting success is the economic
collapse and the ongoing jobs crisis. But this year's record
recruitment can only be fully understood in the context of the
remarkable shift in tactics that began a decade ago.
In 1999, the military had its worst recruiting year in 30, and
Congress called for "aggressive, innovative" new approaches.
Private-sector specialists were brought in, including the top
advertising agency Leo Burnett, and the Army Marketing Brand Group
was formed. A key aim of the new recruitment strategy was to ensure
long-term success by cultivating the allegiance of teenage Americans.
Part of the new campaign, helping the post-9/11 recruiting bump, was
the free video game America's Army. Since its release, different
versions of the war game have been downloaded more than 40 million
times, enough to put it in the Guinness book of world records.
According to a 2008 study by researchers at the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology, "the game had more impact on recruits than
all other forms of Army advertising combined."
America's Army targets 13-to-21-year-olds. The T for Teen rating was
attained because designers were, as one Army spokesman said in 2002,
"very careful on the blood thing." Designers emphasize the game's
realism, but the game is only realistic on a superficial level. Their
conception of authenticity consists of realistic movement, gun clips
that fall away at the right speed, and night vision goggles that make
the same exact whir as the actual goggles do.
The Navy's 10-page graphic novel, "Bravo Zulu," aimed at minority
high school students, was released in May. Its plot is as cartoonish
as its sound effects: "KLANK," "FZZZZZZZ," "KA-KREEK," "FZAAAAAAT."
The Army's graphic novel, "Knowledge is Power," was released in
tandem with "America's Army 3." The graphic novel portrays a staff
sergeant surviving an explosion unharmed. His exclamation to the
rookie soldier who saved him implies that this shows it was wrong to
be "worried about bein' here!"
That these efforts are unfaithful to war's reality has not gone
unnoticed. Protesting the Army Experience Center in Philadelphia,
Sgt. Jesse Hamilton, who served two tours in Iraq and nine total in
the military, expressed disgust that the Army has "resorted to such a
deceiving recruitment strategy."
It's an approach that could have detrimental long-term effects. "The
video game generation is worse at distorting the reality" of war,
according to one Air Force colonel. Although they may be more
talented at operating predator drones, the colonel told the Brookings
Institution, "They don't have that sense of what [is] really going on."
With the war in Iraq and America's surge in Afghanistan, heavy
deployment cycles will undoubtedly extend the military's current
"This is not business as usual," said Mr. Chiarelli of the
"devastating" suicide rate.
To be sure, Vets from World War II and Vietnam had shell shock and
PTSD without video game recruitment, but targeting teens with video
games and graphic novels that ignore the psychological realities of
war is not the way to solve the recruitment problem at a time when
the psychological health of those who are sent to Afghanistan and
Iraq should be a top priority. If recruiting goals can't be met
without employing these deceptive tactics, the military must do
better at explaining just how current engagements protect American interests.
Jamie Holmes is a research associate at New America Foundation.